Thursday, October 05, 2006

Dear Mr Indian Expat

We live in a cosmopolitan and heartland combined society, coupled with many many expatriates due to the call for foreign talent all the time. However, it is interesting to note that local Chinese seldom get along with China Chinese [workers and students alike] and same goes for local Indians and India Indians. We don't really see such a divide between the Malay population in Singapore and that too has us stumped.

But, since we're Yindians. Sometimes, our close cousins from the sub-continent really manage to rile us up. Maybe due to no fault of theirs, maybe they actually know what they're doing. Anyway, here's Nal who works in the technological industry and sometimes deals with her share of smirking foreigners.


Recent events have gotten me so riled against this particular group of people that I have to give vent to my feelings here, before I explode and say something I might regret to their faces.

Dear Indian Expat,

1) You are not smarter than me. Sure, you may have a whole string of alphabets behind your name that your father bought from whichever corrupt university you call your Alma Mater, but that doesn't make you smarter. The only reason you were hired for the job is because no self respecting Singaporean will do that kind of work for that little. In case you didn't know, even peanuts in Singapore is 6 figures per annum.

And as for you "better-than-you" Indian expats that I met at the Comex show - you may think you are all computer geniuses or rocket scientists, and so can't bring yourself to ask an Indian woman for technical specs. What will that do to your barely held-together self respect? Even if she is trained Canon staff. I own this product. I rule this sphere. Geddit?

2) Keep your food morality to yourself. I am really not interested in hearing how meat is bad for you, and how the rancid curd rice your wife packs for you in the morning is so much healthier than food at the hawker centre. In fact we are actually happy you prefer your meals packed in stainless steel "Tiffin" carriers so that we don't have to jostle with you for space during lunch. You might also like to know we actually call them "Tingkat" in Singapore.

3) Teach your children some manners. Granted, children only ape the way their parents behave, and we all know what petulant brats some of you are. But it is NOT acceptable for your kids to be running into people while playing on the train while their mothers sit there and compare the designs on one another's jewellery, or stare daggers at other women who work for a living i.e. me.

4) Singaporean women are not dying to meet Indian expat men. So stop looking at us like we are. We like our men strong, physically fit, independent and manly, the way Singaporean men who have been through NS are. We're not interested in soft in the middle, pansy walking, limp wristed men who lived with their mother and a retinue of servants till they got married.

5) Singaporean Indians have risen above petty differentiators like religion, sect, caste and clan. It is no longer an acceptable conversation starter. So don't think we should fall down and worship you just because you know which caste you belong to. People who cling to age old clan and caste traditions are people who have such low self esteem that they have to hold on to whatever history they can find to validate their existence. Singaporeans are a lot more secure than that. We validate our existence with our bank balances and which secondary schools our kids got into.

Of course, I acknowledge that there are Indian expats who do not deserve this rant and are actually decent human beings. You are hence tasked to teach your countrymen the dos and donts of living in someone else's country. Please. Do us all a favour. Or e-mail us, we can get you some dirt-cheap airfares to return to bustling Bombay.

Editor's Note: Recently, I worked as a BBQ chef part-time. Of all the nationalities at the party, including Germans, Chinese, Japanese, Dutch etc. , only the Indian nationals gave us that sneering, "wait till I tell my son to study hard so he will not have to slave by that hot charcoal pit" look. It's sad really, when they had to put their faces down when at the end of it all the host explained to them we were in fact undergraduates.

Kaps of Sambhar Mafia has left a brilliant counter-comment for this post. Do take the time to read it. This is the kind of two way discussion we hope to promote, instead of plain passive reading of the posts we put up.

, ,
Generated By Technorati Tag Generator

8 comments:

Anonymous said...

i have my fair share of bad experiences working with indian expats in the media industry. being the intern i was at that time, i couldn't retaliate to their daily rants about how screwed up our singapore system is, hw small our flats are, how dumb our children seem to be, the supposed bad lifestyle we lead, how cheap our singapore girls are (i did retaliate to that, shouting at the mofo who said it, and demanded to be let out of the van we were all in. it ended in a shouting fest: SG vs IND) etc etc...all while sitting in a job that could have a singaporean in (if they hate singapore and its citizens so much, why can't they just go back?). the times i wanted to "talk back", i remembered my lecturers telling me not to cause any problems. sighs. there are nice ones, no doubt. but they are overshadowed by the vast majority.

Anonymous said...

Hi I am an Indian myself..and I know some of my countrymen do have the hmm watever things you have said they do! but do realise that there local Indians who also do the same thing..they may not say I am of a higher caste or anything but they do give the look I have more money then I am more richer and of higher class..and there are also local indians.. who look down on students who go of to jcs,sec sch which are of lower rank and why even at students who go of to NTU...so its humnan nature n not only india indians attitude...

Kaps said...

I don't necessarily agree with the charges levelled against expat Indians.
Generalizing that everyone from India has paid money to obtain a degree is a bit far fetched. If a purchased degree is their claim to fame, employers could easily see thru them and fire them if they are found incapable / inequipped to do the job.

Your next charge is that people coming from India are ready to work for less (when compared to locals) and that is one of the reasons why they get recruited. I don't think the Ministry of Manpower will approve the hire in the first case if it can be proved that a foreign talent has been hired primarily to undercut salaries. In the case of foreign workers for lowly skilled jobs and low paying jobs, I can understand that foreign talent is being hired bcoz locals are not willing to do such jobs.
Your tone also suggests that Indians are queuing upto to come to work in Singapore. This is far from true. US, UK, Europe and Australia seem to be among the top choices whether it is for higher studies or for employment. Singapore and the Middle East make up the rest of the list and proximity to their home country is a strong reason for this. There are lot of expat Indians occupying senior positions in Banks, Consulting firms, IT sector etc and they have been offered these jobs mainly bcoz local talent is not available.

You may not be interested in hearing about the story behind somebody behind vegetarian, but atleast respect the right for somebody to be vegetarian or to bring packed lunch from home. I do crib about not getting vegetarian choices at a nearby food court, but I have learnt to cope with it. Even the sights and smells of a food court can come as a shock to Indian vegetarians visiting Singapore for the first time. At the same time, I should admit that Singapore wins praise from Indian tourists and visitors bcoz of the easy access to veg food in Little India as they have a tough time getting veg food is many foreign countries (like Korea, Taiwan etc).

The Singaporean Indian and the Indian Indian has a lot to learn from the other and it is better that we refrain from generalizations and mud-slinging.

Sorry for the long comment.

ah_neh said...

Don't apologize. Much appreciated Kaps.

Nitha said...

hi all... i do agree with some points kaps had mentioned and some by the one who contributed the entry... Lemme share with u an experience i had with some expats...

when i was in poly, my school organised a leadership training programme StarCruise Virgo.. And coincidently.. A grp of expats were( a majaorly big grp i wud say) on board too... Ma frens and i a total of 8 of us, reserved a table at the buffet restraunt for supper. as some of the guys were not in yet, the gals decided to get our food... So leaving one gal behind to "chop place" we went to get our food, when we got back there was another indian lady, apparently an expat, sitting on our table and eating, and her family was sitting on the table next to ours and eating as well.. So not wanting to disturb, i uz sad next to her and started eating and so did my frens...

I noe the gudness of being herbivorous... but its juz too bad tat i was brought up as a omnivorous. the lady had the cheeks to tell me to sit elsewhere if am gonna eat meat... Can ya believe it? she sad on a table allocated for us (it was by the waitress) and she told me to move off?

Another incident that happened in the very cruise was that, ma frens and i were relaxing in a jacuzzi.. some indian expat gals also sat in the same one as us....Out of nowhere, an indian guy (u guessed it rite, an expat!) juz came and sat in the same tub as us..!It was filled with like 6 gals and he uz gave us the kind of "which one can i bang tonite" kind of look...

We came across so many such incidents... We dun hate expats, i mean there are very decent and frenly ones out there too.. but when they do things like this... it gets on our nerves..

sorry for the long entry too guys.. and btw love the blog!

nAl said...

Anon: Acknowledged. Narrow minded bottom feeders exist in every society. Point taken.

Kaps: I appreciate your well thought out arguments, and I beleive that you have probably had similar encounters with Singaporeans of Indian descent. My experience with Indian expats stems from several daily encounters with them, through work (IT industry), social (I volunteer with an Indian non-profit self help org) and play (my neighbourhood). And some of my friends who are also Indian expats tend to share, if not commiserate, with my view.

The main thrust of my post is "when in Rome,...". Even if Singapore is not the first choice adopted home of the Indian expat, he is still bound by societal laws to adapt. Unlike your excellent example, Kaps, many of not learnt to cope, and in fact, shove our "barbarianism" in our faces. Nitha's comment is a good example.

Anonymous said...

I agree that in most cases, it's really a lot better if people learn to live and let live. When comparing Asian (i.e. Indian) expats to European/American expats, one also has to realise that Asian people tend to cling on to their roots a lot more firmly.

And personally, how many of you have gone overseas and wished you were back, or wanted badly, SOME facet of Singapore? (Public transport, abundant food, people who speak proper? English). And having those feelings, we tend to then criticise the environment we have been placed in.

Having said all of that, I'm currently working as a salesperson (serving mostly expats), and my colleagues and I detest serving Indian customers. Granted, there are the occasional few who are courteous and friendly, but the great majority have a "holier than thou" attitude that really gets our collective goat. But of course, instead of saying "Get of of the shop, you *******" (insert desired expletive here), I have to ask, "Would you like to purchase the extended warranty as well?"

jeje said...

longchamp
lebron 13
hermes belt
lebron 13 low
lacoste polo
james harden shoes
yeezy boost 350 v2
asics sneakers
michael kors outlet
yeezy shoes